Journal of Indonesian Thoracic Cardiac and Vascular Surgery

Manuscript Appeal Policy

Authors who believe that a rejection decision was made in error may submit a formal appeal. JINATCVS is committed to a fair, transparent, and impartial appeals process.

JINATCVS respects the editorial process and recognises that, in exceptional circumstances, authors may have valid grounds to appeal a rejection decision. This policy outlines the grounds for appeal, the process for submitting an appeal, and the timelines involved. Appeals are considered at the discretion of the Editor-in-Chief and are not automatic re-submissions.

VALID GROUNDS FOR APPEAL

An appeal may be considered on the following grounds:

Factual error in the review — a reviewer has made a clear factual error or misunderstood a methodological aspect of the study in a way that materially affected their evaluation.
Conflict of interest — the author has evidence that a reviewer had an undisclosed conflict of interest that biased the review.
Process deviation — the editorial process deviated significantly from the journal's published peer review policy in a way that may have unfairly affected the outcome.
Scope misclassification — the manuscript was rejected solely on grounds of scope, but the author believes it clearly falls within the stated scope of the journal and can provide a substantiated argument for this.

Not Valid Grounds for Appeal

The following do not constitute valid grounds for appeal: disagreement with the reviewers' scientific assessment or opinions; desire to revise and resubmit with substantive changes (in such cases, a new submission should be made); or dissatisfaction with the outcome without a specific identifiable error in the review or editorial process.

APPEAL PROCESS

Step 1 — Submit the Appeal

Submit a formal written appeal to the editorial office at editor@jinatcvs.id within 30 days of receiving the rejection decision. Appeals submitted after this period will not be considered unless exceptional circumstances are demonstrated. The subject line must read: "Appeal — [Manuscript ID] — [Manuscript Title]".

Step 2 — Content of the Appeal Letter

The appeal letter must include:

The manuscript ID and title.
A clear statement of the grounds for appeal from those listed above.
A detailed, point-by-point rebuttal addressing the specific error(s) alleged, with reference to the original reviewer comments and decision letter.
Supporting evidence where applicable (e.g., published literature contradicting a reviewer's factual claim).

Note: the appeal letter must not contain a revised version of the manuscript. Appeals are not a mechanism for manuscript revision.

Step 3 — Review of the Appeal

The Editor-in-Chief will review the appeal, the original manuscript, the reviewer comments, and the decision letter. Where appropriate, the Editor-in-Chief may consult a Senior Editorial Board member or commission an additional independent review. The original reviewers are not informed that an appeal has been submitted.

Step 4 — Outcome & Timeline

Authors will be notified of the outcome of their appeal within 30 business days of the appeal being acknowledged. Possible outcomes are: Appeal upheld — the manuscript is returned to peer review or reconsidered; Appeal partially upheld — specific concerns are addressed and/or an additional review is commissioned; Appeal dismissed — the original rejection decision is confirmed. The Editor-in-Chief's decision on the appeal is final. One appeal per manuscript is permitted.

SUBMIT AN APPEAL

Appeal letters should be sent to editor@jinatcvs.id with the subject line "Appeal — [Manuscript ID] — [Title]" within 30 days of the rejection decision. Appeals submitted outside this window or without the required content will not be processed.