Peer Review Policy
Journal of Indonesian Thoracic Cardiac and Vascular Surgery
Peer Review Policy
JINATCVS employs a rigorous double-blind peer review process to ensure the quality, integrity, and scientific validity of all published manuscripts.
JINATCVS employs a double-blind peer review model in which the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process. All manuscripts submitted to JINATCVS are subject to peer review before a final editorial decision is made. The peer review process is guided by the principles established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE).
REVIEW PROCESS AT A GLANCE
Submission & Initial Screening
Upon submission, the editorial office checks the manuscript for completeness, scope alignment, formatting requirements, and obvious ethical issues. Manuscripts that do not meet basic requirements are returned without external review. This stage is typically completed within 5 business days.
Plagiarism Check
All manuscripts that pass initial screening are submitted to a validated similarity detection tool. Manuscripts with a similarity index exceeding 20% (excluding references and standard boilerplate text) will be returned to the authors with a request for revision prior to peer review assignment.
Reviewer Assignment & Double-Blind Anonymisation
The handling editor assigns a minimum of two independent peer reviewers with relevant expertise in the manuscript's subject area. Prior to assignment, all author-identifying information is removed from the manuscript file. Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors at any stage of the process.
Review Period
Reviewers are given a standard review window of 21 days from the date of invitation acceptance. Reviewers may request a single extension of up to 14 days. If a reviewer does not respond within the initial period, the editor will seek a replacement reviewer. The target time from submission to first decision is 6–8 weeks.
Editorial Decision
Based on the reviewers' recommendations, the handling editor makes one of four decisions: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject. The decision is communicated to the corresponding author together with the anonymised reviewers' comments. The Editor-in-Chief holds final authority over all publication decisions.
Revision, Re-review & Final Decision
Authors whose manuscripts require revision must submit their revised manuscript along with a detailed point-by-point response letter within 30 days (minor) or 60 days (major). Revised manuscripts may be sent to the original reviewers or to new reviewers at the editor's discretion. A manuscript that requires more than two rounds of major revision may be rejected.
CRITERIA FOR MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION
Reviewers are asked to evaluate manuscripts against the following criteria:
Scientific Originality & Novelty — Does the manuscript present new and original findings or perspectives? Is the contribution meaningful to the field of thoracic, cardiac, and vascular surgery?
Methodological Rigour — Are the study design, methodology, statistical analysis, and interpretation of results scientifically sound and clearly described?
Clinical Relevance & Significance — Does the work have clear implications for clinical practice, surgical techniques, or patient outcomes in cardiovascular and thoracic medicine?
Ethical Compliance — Does the manuscript include adequate disclosure of ethics committee approval, informed consent, conflict of interest, and funding sources?
Clarity & Presentation — Is the manuscript clearly written, logically structured, and appropriately referenced? Are figures, tables, and data presented accurately and readably?
Appropriate Scope — Does the subject matter fall within the scope of JINATCVS (thoracic, cardiac, and vascular surgery including endovascular and minimally invasive approaches)?
CONFIDENTIALITY & REVIEWER INTEGRITY
Strict Confidentiality
Reviewers must treat all manuscripts received for review as strictly confidential documents. The content of a manuscript under review, including its data, ideas, and conclusions, must not be shared with, or discussed with, any other person without the express permission of the Editor-in-Chief. Reviewers must not use unpublished information from a manuscript under review for their own research.
Conflict of Interest Declaration
Reviewers who have a conflict of interest with the authors, institutions, or subject matter of a manuscript — including competitive, collaborative, financial, or personal relationships — must disclose this to the editor immediately upon receiving the review invitation. In such cases, the reviewer must decline the invitation. The editor will then identify an alternative reviewer.
Reviewer Recognition
JINATCVS acknowledges the invaluable contribution of peer reviewers to the quality of the published literature. An annual list of reviewers who contributed to the journal is published in the December issue. Reviewers who provide thorough, timely, and constructive feedback are invited for recognition in the journal's annual acknowledgement. Reviewers may also log their contributions on platforms such as Publons / Web of Science Reviewer Recognition.
INDICATIVE TIMELINE
JOIN OUR REVIEWER PANEL
We welcome qualified specialists in thoracic surgery, cardiac surgery, vascular surgery, and endovascular surgery to join our panel of peer reviewers. Reviewers must hold a relevant postgraduate specialist qualification (Sp.BTKV or equivalent international certification) and be actively engaged in clinical practice or academic research.
To register as a reviewer, please contact the editorial office at editor@jinatcvs.id with your CV and a brief statement of your areas of expertise.