Journal of Indonesian Thoracic Cardiac and Vascular Surgery

Generative AI Policy

JINATCVS endorses transparent, responsible use of AI-assisted tools in scholarly research and writing, in full accordance with COPE and ICMJE guidance.


COPE ALIGNED ICMJE ALIGNED DISCLOSURE REQUIRED

JINATCVS recognises that generative artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted tools are increasingly used in academic research and scientific writing. The journal's policy is guided by the principles established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). The core principle is that accountability for published work must rest with human authors — not with AI systems.

AI TOOLS & AUTHORSHIP

AI Cannot Be Listed as an Author

Generative AI tools — including but not limited to ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot, and similar large language model (LLM) systems — cannot be listed as authors on any manuscript submitted to JINATCVS. Authorship requires the ability to give informed consent, take accountability for the work, and meet all ICMJE authorship criteria. AI systems cannot fulfil these responsibilities.

Human Authors Bear Full Responsibility

Named human authors are fully responsible for the accuracy, integrity, and originality of all content in their manuscript, including any content that was drafted or assisted by AI tools. The use of an AI tool does not diminish or transfer the author's responsibility for the work. Authors must verify all AI-generated content for factual accuracy, appropriate citation, and absence of fabricated references or data.

PERMITTED USES OF AI TOOLS

Use Case Permitted? Disclosure Required?
Grammar and language editing Yes Yes — in Acknowledgements
Summarising or synthesising literature (as a research tool) Yes Yes — in Methods or Acknowledgements
Generating manuscript text (sections or full drafts) Conditional Yes — mandatory, in Methods section
Statistical analysis or data interpretation Conditional Yes — in Methods, with validation statement
Creating, editing, or manipulating figures or images Conditional Yes — in figure legend and Methods
Fabricating, inventing, or manipulating research data Never N/A — constitutes research misconduct

HOW TO DISCLOSE AI USE

Where to Disclose

AI tool use must be disclosed in the Methods section (for use in data analysis, image generation, or content generation integral to the research) and/or the Acknowledgements section (for use in language editing or other supporting tasks). The disclosure must specify the tool used, its version where relevant, and the nature of its use.

Example Disclosure Language

"Language editing assistance was provided by [AI tool name, version/date accessed]. The authors have reviewed and verified all content and take full responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of the submitted manuscript."

"[AI tool name] was used to assist in [specific task, e.g., summarising search results / generating initial code for statistical analysis]. All outputs were independently verified by the authors."

AI USE BY REVIEWERS & EDITORS

Peer reviewers and editors must not upload any manuscript submitted to JINATCVS into a public or third-party AI tool, as this would breach the journal's confidentiality requirements. Reviewers may use AI tools to assist with grammar or clarity in their own written review comments, provided they take full responsibility for the content of their review and do not share the manuscript's content with the tool. The editorial board may update these guidelines as AI capabilities and publishing norms evolve.

GOVERNING STANDARDS

This policy is aligned with the COPE Position Statement on AI and authorship and the ICMJE recommendations on the use of AI in scientific publications. Questions regarding AI use in a specific manuscript may be directed to the editorial office at editor@jinatcvs.id.