Correction & Retraction Policies
Journal of Indonesian Thoracic Cardiac and Vascular Surgery
Correction & Retraction Policies
JINATCVS is committed to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record and follows COPE guidelines for post-publication corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions.
COPE COMPLIANT
The integrity of the published scientific record is of paramount importance to JINATCVS. The journal takes all reasonable steps to ensure accuracy before publication, but acknowledges that errors and concerns may arise after a manuscript has been published. This policy describes how the journal handles post-publication corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions in accordance with the COPE Retraction Guidelines and COPE Guidelines on Corrections and Expressions of Concern.
1. CORRECTIONS
Corrigendum (Author Error)
A Corrigendum is published when the authors identify a significant error in their published article that does not materially affect the conclusions of the study. This notice corrects specific elements of the article — such as a misstatement of a statistical value, an error in a figure label, or an incorrect affiliation — and is linked bidirectionally to the original article. The original published article remains available and is labelled as having a correction. Minor typographical errors that do not affect content or meaning are corrected directly in the online version without a separate notice.
Erratum (Publisher / Editorial Error)
An Erratum is published when a significant error introduced during the editorial or production process (e.g., a figure corrupted during typesetting, text altered in copyediting) is identified after publication. The erratum is linked bidirectionally to the affected article. JINATCVS takes responsibility for errors introduced at the editorial or production stage and issues an erratum promptly upon discovery or notification.
How to Request a Correction
Authors who identify an error in their published article should contact the editorial office at editor@jinatcvs.id with the subject line "Correction Request — [Manuscript Title / DOI]". The request must specify the exact nature of the error, the correct information, and the reason the error occurred. The editorial board will assess the request and, if appropriate, issue a correction notice.
2. EXPRESSION OF CONCERN
JINATCVS may publish an Expression of Concern when a serious concern is raised about the integrity of a published article — such as possible data fabrication, undisclosed conflict of interest, or unresolved authorship dispute — but where a definitive determination of misconduct has not yet been reached and the matter is under investigation. An Expression of Concern will be linked bidirectionally to the article, will clearly state the nature of the concern, and will be updated or replaced with a correction or retraction notice once the investigation is concluded.
3. RETRACTIONS
Grounds for Retraction
A published article may be retracted on any of the following grounds:
Retraction Process
Upon identification of a potential ground for retraction, the Editor-in-Chief will initiate an investigation in accordance with COPE flowcharts, contacting the corresponding author and, where appropriate, the author's institution. Authors will be given the opportunity to respond before a retraction decision is finalised. The Editor-in-Chief holds final authority over retraction decisions. Authors, readers, and third parties may report concerns about published articles to editor@jinatcvs.id.
Retraction Notice & Preservation of Record
When an article is retracted, a retraction notice is published and linked bidirectionally to the original article. The retraction notice states the reason for retraction clearly and impartially. The original article remains available in the published record but is clearly and permanently marked "RETRACTED" in both the HTML and PDF versions, with the retraction notice date and DOI displayed prominently. The DOI of the retracted article remains active and resolves to the retracted version.
REPORT A CONCERN
Concerns about published articles in JINATCVS may be submitted confidentially to the editorial office at editor@jinatcvs.id with the subject line "Post-Publication Concern — [Article DOI]". All reports are handled in accordance with COPE guidelines and treated with appropriate confidentiality.