Author Guidelines
Journal of Indonesian Thoracic Cardiac and Vascular Surgery
Author Guidelines
Everything you need to know before submitting your manuscript to JINATCVS.
→ Submit Manuscript
CONTENTS
1. General Information
JINATCVS welcomes contributions that advance knowledge and foster evidence-based discussion among cardiothoracic and vascular surgeons worldwide. The journal publishes original research, clinical studies, systematic reviews, and case reports in thoracic, cardiac, and vascular surgery.
All manuscripts must be written in clear, concise English, following the standards of scientific writing outlined in the Scientific Style and Format by the Council of Science Editors (CSE), 7th edition.
Originality requirement: Only manuscripts not previously published (in print or electronically) and not currently under review elsewhere will be considered. Prior presentation at a scientific symposium does not preclude submission.
Plagiarism policy: All submissions are screened using Turnitin. Authors who submit previously published work will be permanently banned from future submissions, and their institution and/or funding body will be notified.
2. Mandatory Pre-submission Checklist
Manuscripts missing any of the following items will be automatically rejected without review.
1. Ethical Clearance
Provide the ethical clearance record number and a copy of the approval document. For case series or case reports, the patient/family informed consent (in English) and the completed ICMJE form must also be submitted.
2. Conflict of Interest Disclosure
All authors must disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest, including financial relationships. Complete and submit the ICMJE Conflict of Interest Disclosure Form →
3. Funding Statement
Include a funding statement in the manuscript. If the study received no external funding, explicitly state: "This study received no external funding." Complete and submit the ICMJE Disclosure Form →
4. Author Contribution Statement
List each author's specific contribution using the CRediT taxonomy (e.g., Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – Original Draft, etc.). Each author's role must be clearly specified.
5. Self-Citation / Self-Referencing Statement
Authors must declare any self-citations within the manuscript. Excessive self-citation is considered a breach of publication ethics and may result in rejection.
6. Generative AI Disclosure Form
Disclose any use of AI or AI-assisted tools in the preparation of the manuscript. See Section 3 for the full AI Use & Disclosure Policy.
3. AI Use & Disclosure Policy
Policy Statement
JINATCVS follows the guidelines established by COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) and ICMJE regarding the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies in scientific writing. Authors are required to be fully transparent about any AI tool used during manuscript preparation.
Permitted AI Uses
• Language editing and grammar correction
• Summarizing or organizing existing content
• Literature search assistance
• Formatting and reference management
Not Permitted
• AI tools cannot be listed as authors under any circumstances
• AI-generated data, fabricated results, or hallucinated references
• Using AI to bypass ethical or scientific responsibilities
• Undisclosed AI use in any part of the manuscript
Disclosure requirement: Authors must disclose — in the Methods section or Acknowledgments — the name of the AI tool, its version, the provider, and a description of how it was used. The corresponding author takes full responsibility for the integrity of all AI-assisted content. Failure to disclose AI use constitutes a breach of publication ethics and may result in retraction.
4. Double-Blind Peer Review Process
The review process at JINATCVS is double-blind: neither the reviewers' nor the authors' names are revealed to the other party at any stage of review.
Step 1 — Submission
Submit two separate files to ensure anonymity during review:
File 1 — Title Page
Title, all author names & affiliations, corresponding author's full contact details (address, phone, email).
File 2 — Blinded Manuscript
Complete manuscript with no author names, affiliations, or any identifying information.
Blinding checklist:
› Refer to own prior work in third person: write "[Anonymous, 2022]" instead of "as we showed..."
› Remove all affiliation-related identifiers from figures, tables, and image metadata
› In the reference list: "[Anonymous 2022] Information withheld for double-blind reviewing"
› Remove acknowledgments, funding sources, and grant numbers
› Remove author names from file names and document properties (File → Info → Remove Personal Information)
Step 2 — Initial Evaluation
The editorial team checks: (a) relevance to JINATCVS scope, (b) English language quality, (c) completeness of all six mandatory pre-submission items, and (d) overall compliance with formatting guidelines. Manuscripts failing any of these checks will be returned without peer review.
Step 3 — Peer Review
Manuscripts passing the initial check are evaluated by at least two independent expert reviewers in the relevant subspecialty. Reviewers assess scientific rigor, clinical relevance, methodology, and adherence to reporting guidelines.
Authors have 7 days to respond to reviewer comments and resubmit the revised manuscript. The reviewer then makes a final recommendation: Accept / Minor Revision / Major Revision / Reject.
Step 4 — Editorial Decision & Publication
Accepted manuscripts are sent to the editor for final copy-editing and proofreading. The corresponding author must approve the final galley proof before the article is published online.
5. Authorship
All authors must meet ALL four ICMJE criteria:
• Substantial contributions to conception/design, data collection, analysis, or interpretation.
• Drafting the manuscript or critically revising it for important intellectual content.
• Final approval of the version to be published.
• Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, including accuracy and integrity.
Acknowledgements
Contributors who do not meet all authorship criteria (e.g., technical support, statistical consultation, writing assistance) should be listed in the Acknowledgements section with a description of their contribution.
Author Order & Changes
Changes to the author list — including adding, removing, or reordering authors — are not permitted after submission. All authors must verify the author list and order carefully before submitting. Post-submission changes require written justification and approval by all authors and the Editor-in-Chief.
6. Manuscript Format
Font & Typography
12pt Times New Roman, justified margins, double-spaced throughout.
File Format
Microsoft Word (.doc / .docx) only. PDF submissions are not accepted for initial review.
Line Numbering
Continuous line numbering must be applied from title to the end of the references (Layout → Line Numbers → Continuous in Microsoft Word).
Document Cleanliness
No endnotes, headers, or footers. Remove track changes and comments before submission.
Title Page
Must include: brief running title (max 50 characters), full name of each author (first name, middle initial, last name), institutional affiliations in English, corresponding author's full address, phone, and email. Also state: word count, number of tables, and number of figures.
7. Article Types & Structure
1. Original Research Articles
Max words: 4,000 (excluding abstract and references) | Max references: 40 | Max tables/figures: 6 combined
Required structure: Title → Abstract (max 300 words, structured: Background / Methods / Results / Conclusion) → Keywords (min. 4, max 8) → Introduction → Methods → Results → Discussion → Conclusion → Ethical Consideration → Funding → Conflict of Interest → Author Contributions → References → Tables → Figures & Legends.
RCT registration: All Randomized Controlled Trials must be prospectively registered in an ICMJE-accepted trial registry (e.g., ClinicalTrials.gov, WHO ICTRP). The registration number must appear at the end of the abstract.
2. Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
Max words: 6,000 | Max references: 80 | PRISMA checklist required
In-depth, critical, and interpretive analyses of current evidence in cardiothoracic and vascular surgery. Must include a PRISMA flow diagram and follow current PRISMA 2020 reporting guidelines.
PROSPERO registration: All systematic reviews and meta-analyses must be prospectively registered in PROSPERO. The registration number must appear at the end of the abstract and in the Methods section.
3. Narrative Review Articles
Max words: 5,000 | Max references: 60 | Invited or unsolicited
Comprehensive overviews of a topic of clinical importance in thoracic, cardiac, or vascular surgery. Must describe current evidence, identify knowledge gaps, and provide clinical implications.
4. Case Report / Case Series
Max words: 2,000 | Max references: 20 | CARE guidelines required
Must include: (a) written informed consent from patient or guardian; (b) valid IRB/ethics committee approval or waiver number; and (c) high-quality, de-identified clinical images (intraoperative photographs, CT, MRI, angiography, or pathology) with descriptive captions. Follow the CARE (CAse REport) guidelines.
8. Reporting Guidelines
JINATCVS requires authors to adhere to internationally recognized reporting guidelines appropriate to the study design. The relevant completed checklist must be submitted alongside the manuscript.
CONSORT
Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) — with CONSORT flow diagram and completed checklist.
STROBE
Observational studies (cohort, case-control, cross-sectional).
PRISMA 2020
Systematic reviews and meta-analyses — with PRISMA flow diagram.
CARE
Case reports and case series.
STARD
Diagnostic accuracy studies.
9. Tables & Figures
Tables
• Double-spaced, placed on separate pages at the end of the document (after References)
• Created using Word's "Insert Table" function — no tabs or spaces to simulate table structure
• Unit symbols placed in column headings only; define all abbreviations/acronyms in the table legend
• No shading; footnote symbols: *, †, ‡, §, ||, ¶, #, **, ††, ‡‡
• Tables reproduced from other sources require written permission and proper attribution
Figures & Clinical Images
• Minimum 300 DPI resolution; sized to final print dimensions (1–2 column width)
• Accepted formats: TIFF, EPS, PDF (vector-based); avoid JPEGs for line art or graphs
• Fonts 8–10pt at 100%; style must be consistent across all figures in the manuscript
• Faces and identifiable features of patients must be blinded unless explicit written consent has been obtained and submitted
• Intraoperative and clinical photographs must be of sufficient quality to demonstrate the surgical technique or finding clearly
• Radiological images (CT angiography, echocardiography, fluoroscopy): submit as DICOM-derived high-resolution exports with annotated arrows or labels
• Multi-panel figures labeled A, B, C; described fully in the legend, not in the image file itself
• Figure legends placed at the end of the text section, not embedded in image files
Abbreviations
Use only when necessary (lengthy chemical names, terms repeated ≥3 times). Define at first use in the abstract and again at first use in the main text.
Units of Measurement
Use SI units throughout. Non-SI equivalents may be added in parentheses where clinically relevant (e.g., blood pressure in mmHg is acceptable).
10. References — Vancouver Style
References must follow the Vancouver Style, numbered sequentially in order of first citation in the text. All authors must be listed; use "et al." only when there are more than 6 authors. Include inclusive page numbers. Journal abbreviations follow the NLM (National Library of Medicine) List of Journals Indexed for Medline.
Format Examples
Coselli JS, LeMaire SA, Preventza O, de la Cruz KI, et al. Outcomes of 3309 thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm repairs. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2016;151(5):1323–38. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jtcvs.2015.12.050
Harky A, Ahmad MU, Sadeque S, et al. Open versus endovascular repair of descending thoracic aortic aneurysm: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann Vasc Surg. 2020;67:44–55. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.avsg.2020.03.019
Non-Compliance Warning
If your paper is accepted but does not meet the formatting requirements, your publication date may be delayed until corrections are made. Manuscripts missing any of the six mandatory pre-submission items will be automatically rejected without review.
Ready to Submit?
Ensure all six mandatory items are complete before submitting through the OJS portal.
Submit Manuscript → Visit Journal Website →